← Back to Blog For Parents

How to Choose the Right Online Tutor for Your Child

By the Peakly Education Team • March 2026 • 6 min read

The online tutoring market has exploded in recent years, and for good reason. Online tutoring offers flexibility, access to a wider pool of experts, and the convenience of learning from home. But with thousands of tutors available across dozens of platforms, how do you find the right one for your child? Not all tutors are equal, and a poor match can waste money and, worse, damage your child's confidence.

This guide walks you through what to look for, what questions to ask, and the warning signs that suggest a tutor is not the right fit.

1. Subject Knowledge vs. Teaching Ability

The most common mistake parents make is equating subject expertise with teaching ability. A university professor with a PhD in mathematics may be brilliant at research but terrible at explaining fractions to a Year 7 student. Conversely, a recent university graduate who aced the same curriculum your child is studying may be the perfect tutor because they remember exactly where students get confused.

What matters most is the tutor's ability to:

• Explain concepts at your child's level, not their own level.
• Recognise when a student is confused, even if they do not say so.
• Adapt their teaching approach when something is not working.
• Break complex problems into smaller, manageable steps.

Ask potential tutors: "How would you explain [a concept your child is struggling with] to my child?" Their answer will tell you more than any credential.

2. Check for Relevant Experience

Experience matters, but the type of experience matters more than the quantity. A tutor with ten years of experience teaching university students may not be effective with a primary school child. Look for experience that matches your child's specific situation:

• Curriculum knowledge: Do they know the Australian Curriculum, VCE, HSC, or whatever framework your child is studying? A tutor familiar with the specific syllabus will know exactly what the assessments require.
• Age-appropriate teaching: Teaching a 10-year-old requires different skills than teaching a 17-year-old. Ask about the age range they typically work with.
• Exam preparation: If your child needs help preparing for NAPLAN, VCE, HSC, or selective entry exams, look for tutors who have specifically helped students with those assessments.

3. Look for a Structured Approach

A good tutor does not just show up and ask "What do you need help with today?" While flexibility is important, effective tutoring follows a structured approach:

1. Assessment: The tutor should start by understanding where your child is right now—what they know well and where the gaps are.
2. Goal setting: Together with you and your child, they should set clear, measurable goals. "Improve maths" is not a goal. "Move from a C to a B in algebra by the end of term" is.
3. Planned sessions: Each session should have a clear focus and build on the previous one, not be a random collection of problems.
4. Progress tracking: You should receive regular updates on what has been covered, where progress has been made, and what still needs work.

"The best tutors I have worked with always started with a diagnostic. They figured out exactly where my son was getting stuck before they started teaching anything new. That saved us weeks of time." — Parent of a Year 10 student

4. Questions to Ask Before Booking

Do not be afraid to interview potential tutors. A good tutor will welcome your questions because they understand that fit matters. Here are the key questions to ask:

• "What is your experience with the [specific curriculum/exam]?" You want specifics, not generalities.
• "How do you handle a student who is not engaging or seems unmotivated?" This reveals their approach to the emotional side of learning.
• "What does a typical session look like?" Listen for structure: warm-up, new content, practice, review.
• "How do you communicate progress to parents?" You should expect regular updates, not silence between sessions.
• "Can we do a trial session?" Any tutor confident in their ability will offer this. Be wary of those who demand long-term commitments upfront.
• "What resources do you use?" Good tutors use a mix of textbook exercises, past exam papers, and their own materials tailored to the student's needs.

5. Red Flags to Watch For

In our experience at Peakly, these warning signs indicate a tutor may not be the right choice:

• They do the work for your child: A tutor should guide your child to the answer, not give it to them. If your child's homework is suddenly perfect but they cannot explain how they got the answers, the tutor is doing too much.
• No improvement after 6-8 sessions: While every student progresses at a different pace, you should see some measurable improvement within two months. If nothing has changed, the approach is not working.
• They are always available: This might sound counterintuitive, but a tutor who has unlimited availability often lacks other students, which may indicate quality issues. Good tutors are in demand.
• They cannot explain their method: If a tutor cannot articulate how they plan to help your child improve, they probably do not have a plan.
• They discourage questions: A tutor who gets impatient with questions or makes your child feel stupid for not understanding is actively harmful.
• No Working with Children Check: In Australia, anyone working with children should have a current WWCC. This is non-negotiable.

6. Online vs. In-Person: What to Consider

Online tutoring has become the default for many families, and for good reason. However, it is worth understanding the trade-offs:

Advantages of online tutoring:

• Access to a much wider pool of qualified tutors, not limited by geography.
• No travel time for either party.
• Sessions can be recorded for later review.
• Screen sharing makes it easy to work through digital resources together.
• Often more affordable than in-person tutoring.

When in-person might be better:

• Very young children (under 8) who struggle to focus on a screen.
• Students who need hands-on activities (e.g., science experiments, art).
• Students with attention difficulties who benefit from physical presence.

For most students aged 10 and above, online tutoring is just as effective as in-person tutoring when the tutor is skilled at using the digital tools available.

7. How to Evaluate After the First Few Sessions

After three to four sessions, check in with your child and ask:

• Do you feel comfortable asking questions?
• Do you understand things better after the session than before?
• Is the tutor going at the right pace—not too fast, not too slow?
• Do you look forward to the sessions, or dread them?

Also look for objective signs of progress: improved test scores, more confidence with homework, a willingness to attempt problems they would previously have skipped. If your child actively looks forward to their tutoring sessions, you have found a great match.

Final Thoughts

Choosing the right tutor is one of the highest-impact investments you can make in your child's education. The key is to look beyond credentials and focus on teaching ability, communication style, and fit with your child's personality and learning needs. Do not settle for "good enough"—the difference between an adequate tutor and an excellent one can be the difference between a student who tolerates a subject and one who genuinely understands and enjoys it.